The film follows Eugene (played by Anika Duffield), a quirky grocery store detective who has a crush on a charming but shallow boy named Sam (Sam Snedden). The twist? Sam rejects Eugene because she is "bad in bed." Convinced that her lack of sexual experience is the problem, Eugene embarks on a haphazard mission to become a "carnivore" (a sexual predator) by seducing random, unsuitable men to practice her techniques.